Delicious Watermelon and Feta Salad with Mint You’ll Love

Watermelon and Feta Salad with Mint is practically made for days when you just cannot deal with a hot stove. Picture this: you open your fridge, and what do you see? Gorgeous, ruby-red watermelon staring back at you, waiting to save your overly-warm day. Or maybe you just got back from the market and hauled home a melon the size of a toddler (oops, did you need all that?). Don’t sweat it. I’ve totally been there. You should check out these zesty salad ideas if you want even more inspiration like this refreshing watermelon and mint salad zesty twist and if you’re feeling wild after, some refreshing watermelon mint popsicles will blow your mind. So yeah, you’re about to meet your new favorite summer side.

How to Choose the Most Flavorful Watermelon

You ever bring home a watermelon, cut into it, and—ugh—inside it’s pale, spongy, and sad? Happens to the best of us. Let me give you a few tips (I’ve made enough watermelon salad disasters for all of us).

Honestly, the most flavorful watermelon feels heavy for its size. Like, more than you’d expect. Heft it in your hands at the store. Next, check for a big creamy-yellow spot on the rind. That’s called a field spot. The bigger and butterier that spot is, the longer your watermelon’s been ripening under the sun.
Knock on it. I know, you’ll look odd in the aisle. But a hollow sound means it’s probably juicy inside. If it sounds thuddy or dull, maybe move along. Also, shiny skin isn’t actually ideal. You’re looking for a matte finish—it’s less underripe that way. Finally, grab a pre-cut wedge to eyeball the deepness of its pink/red color if you need to. Oh, and personal rant: seedless or seeded, totally your call.

Good watermelon just makes or breaks this salad, so don’t skip this part.

What’s the Best Feta for Salad?

Alright, tiny confession time. I used to buy those crumbly pre-packed feta tubs because—uh—convenience. Then I tried a block of feta packed in brine for my watermelon and feta salad with mint and, wow, there’s a night and day difference.

If you can, go for Greek feta that comes in a block. It’s tangy, crazy creamy, and a little crumbly (but not dry). Look for one that says it’s in “brine”—that liquid helps it stay really fresh and flavorful. Avoid the dry pre-crumbled stuff if you can help it. Sometimes, I even rinse it ever so slightly if I want a milder vibe. Oh, and I once tried a goat’s milk feta because it was on sale. Not bad! Sheep’s milk is the classic, but both work. So, you really can’t mess this up unless you forget the feta altogether, and then, come on, it’s not watermelon and feta salad with mint anymore.

Bonus table for feta nerds:

Type of Feta	Milk Used	Flavor Notes	Texture
Greek (Sheep/Goat)	Sheep (or sheep & goat)	Briny, tangy, creamy	Creamy, crumbly
Bulgarian	Sheep	Salty, rich, sharp	Softer, creamy
Danish (Cow)	Cow	Milder, less salty	Very soft, less crumbly

Watermelon Feta Salad Dressing

Here’s the truth: complicated dressings sort of ruin the best thing about watermelon and feta salad with mint. You want bright, zingy, quick, not fussy. My go-to? Squeeze of lime, maybe a teeny bit of honey, glug of olive oil, and a pinch of salt.

Don’t douse it, just toss and move on. Sometimes I add a swirl of balsamic glaze to finish—that’s another level, if you ask me, but not required. If you’re out of lime, a bit of lemon juice totally works. And heck, a grind or two of black pepper doesn’t hurt either, especially with the mint going on. Quick tip: always dress the salad right before serving. Nobody likes soggy melon, right?

One more thing—I always taste as I go, since watermelons are all over the place with sweetness. And if your feta is ultra-salty, cool it with extra salt in the dressing. Sometimes, less is more.

Make this Watermelon Salad Your Own

Listen, strict recipes aren’t my thing. Watermelon and feta salad with mint loves to be customized. If you want to go off the beaten salad path, here’s what I’ve tried (and eaten embarrassingly fast):

Add some arugula—peppery greens work so well here. Toss in thin-sliced cucumber for crunch. Red onion? Go for it, just soak the slices in cold water to tame them down. Jalapeño? If you’re brave (trust me, tiny bits though). I’m a sucker for roasted pistachios or walnuts sprinkled on top for extra texture. Uh, and if you’re grilling already, try grilled watermelon, just for the heck of it. That deep smoky thing with feta is wild. You could swap mint for basil if it’s what you’ve got. Oh shoot, I even once mixed in a little creamy watermelon smoothie on the side for brunch vibes.

Don’t stress if your bowl doesn’t look just like someone’s photo—half the point is making it your own.

What to Serve with Watermelon Salad

This is the million-dollar question. Watermelon and feta salad with mint goes with basically everything if you ask my summer self, but for those trying to make a plan, here are some (maybe odd, but perfect) ideas:

• Grilled chicken or delicious batch cooked chicken breast for salads
• Fish tacos or crispy shrimp (make it coastal)
• A simple baguette and herby butter
• Slap it next to a burger or BBQ spread—super refreshing

Don’t be afraid to use the leftovers. Ah, who am I kidding, there are never leftovers.

Common Questions

Q: Can I make watermelon and feta salad with mint ahead of time?
A: Sort of. Prep the ingredients separately, but mix them just before serving. It keeps everything crisp.

Q: I’m not into mint—what else can I use?
A: Basil or even cilantro work! Feel free to mix and match.

Q: Are there any no-dairy options?
A: Yes! Try cubed avocado or dairy-free feta, or even olives for salty flavor.

Q: Does it keep well in the fridge?
A: Eh, not really. Watermelon releases juice fast, so it gets soggy. Best eaten fresh.

Q: Can I add anything spicy?
A: Go wild and toss in sliced jalapeños or chili flakes if you want a little heat.

This watermelon and feta salad with mint is so delicious and refreshing—it’s my absolute favorite for picnics! I get so many requests for the recipe every time. -Katie, neighbor and self-proclaimed “melon queen”

Ready for a Fresh Summer Favorite?

Okay, so here’s the deal: a few smart tricks, the best ingredients you can swing, and watermelon and feta salad with mint might just steal the whole cookout. Don’t get too hung up on fancy rules. And hey, why not check out other expert spins like the Watermelon, Feta, and Mint Salad Recipe or tasty combos like Watermelon Salad with Feta, Cucumber and Mint? Seriously, your backyard (or, you know, your kitchen table) deserves five-star flavor. Go give it a try—experience a summer classic with your own twist!

Print