Irresistibly Homemade Sourdough French Toast for Lazy Mornings

Have you ever woken up dreaming of Ultimate Homemade Sourdough French Toast but the thought of cleaning 500 pans made you almost roll over and go back to sleep? Same. Nobody wants chaos for breakfast. Yet, here I am, telling you this sourdough French toast is so simple you’ll actually make it even before your coffee. Actually, why not pair it with something from this list of the 10 best homemade coffee recipes while you’re at it? And maybe dream ahead to brunch with some next-level avocado toast with poached egg. Let’s just say, breakfast might fast become your new favorite meal.

Ingredient Notes

Alright, let’s hit the basics first, because this is not the time for fancy-pants shopping. Honestly, the main reason I adore this Ultimate Homemade Sourdough French Toast is—nine times outta ten—I already have everything I need.

Sourdough is my hero here. It’s got that tang, holds up to soaking, and isn’t afraid of a crisp. Slice it thick. You want it sturdy. Eggs are your builder, and milk makes it all creamy dreamy. I like full-fat but don’t sweat it if you only have 2%. Vanilla? Absolute must. It covers a multitude of sins like slightly stale bread or that time you accidentally bought unsalted butter. Cinnamon and maybe a pinch of salt to wake everybody up.

Let’s not ignore the toppings: maple syrup is the obvious choice, but berries, powdered sugar, or if you wanna be fancy, check out this delicious summer berry ricotta toast for ideas. Bottom line—don’t overthink it. Use what’s in reach. Wonky bits of bread? It’ll soak up custard beautifully. Extra eggs? No one’s mad about that.

The first time I tried this recipe, my kids finished every single slice and THEN begged for more. That’s a miracle on a school morning. This Ultimate Homemade Sourdough French Toast is now a must-make in our house!

Variations

French toast likes to play dress-up. If you’re into experimenting (I am, because breakfast needs a remix sometimes), try this:

Pump in some nutmeg for a warmer flavor. Feeling extra luxurious? Swap out milk for half-and-half or even a splash of heavy cream. Have some leftover pumpkin puree? Whisk in a tablespoon or two for autumn flair. Not everyone loves cinnamon, and hey, cardamom is waiting to be discovered.

You can use day-old brioche if sourdough vanished from your counter. But honestly, Ultimate Homemade Sourdough French Toast has a character no other bread can copy. Oh, and if gluten-free is your rodeo—there’s sourdough for that, too.

Chocolate chips in the egg mixture are a win for kids (or, let’s be honest, adults on Mondays). I once tried grated orange zest and wow—next-level brunch vibes, zero regrets.

Some folks love stuffed French toast. Mash cream cheese and jam between bread slices, dip as usual, cook and you’ll look like someone who brunches professionally. Wonky? Sometimes, but delicious every time.

How to Make Sourdough French Toast

Making this isn’t rocket science. No, it’s definitely easier. Here’s exactly how I roll out of bed and wow everyone (or, well, myself):

Crack a couple eggs into a wide, shallow bowl. Add milk, vanilla, a fat pinch of cinnamon, and a wee bit of salt. Whisk it like it owes you money until it’s blended. Dunk those thick slices of sourdough in your batter, letting them hang out for a moment so they soak a bit.

Heat a skillet or frying pan with butter. Let it sizzle. Place each soaked slice into the pan carefully. Don’t crowd them, okay? Give them space to become the toast heroes they were born to be.

Cook both sides until golden—sometimes, I get distracted and they get extra crispy. Nobody ever complains. Stack, syrup, devour.

Tips for Making the Best Sourdough French Toast

Let’s talk survival skills. Not like camping, but like making breakfast without losing your mind. Trust me, I’ve ruined a few breakfasts.

If your bread is too soft, let it get slightly stale—Ultimate Homemade Sourdough French Toast is actually better this way. Don’t skimp on soaking, but if you let the bread turn to soup, game over. Let it rest just enough to get pillowy, not soggy. Medium-low heat works magic by giving the center time to set without charring the crust.

A little patience with flipping makes all the difference. Rushing means you end up with French toast scrambled eggs. That’s a real thing (but not in a good way). Also, treat yourself by warming the syrup. It’s a small touch, but worth it.

Hungry for more cozy breakfasts? Try my homemade fluffy cinnamon rolls if you want something with that bakery smell.

How to Store

You thought you’d have leftovers? That’s rich. But if you do, here’s how not to ruin all your hard work.

Pop cooled slices in an airtight container. They’ll last in the fridge about three days, but honestly, fresher is better. Want to freeze? Go for it—just separate slices with parchment and freeze up to two months.

Reheating is best in a pan on the stove to revive the crust, but toaster ovens are solid, too. Microwave only if you’re in a real pinch. Trust me, it gets floppy.

Serving Suggestions

• Pile high with fresh berries and real maple syrup.
• A dollop of whipped cream takes it to five-star-restaurant-luxury, no joke.
• Feeling savory? Give it a side of crispy bacon or dreamy scrambled eggs.
• Try drizzling with some of this deliciously easy homemade stovetop apple butter for a serious fall brunch vibe.

Common Questions

Can I make Ultimate Homemade Sourdough French Toast ahead of time?
You can! It does pretty well if you prep the night before and just reheat in the morning, though nothing quite beats it fresh.

Is sourdough healthier for French toast?
I mean, probably a little. The tangy flavor also makes it taste like you know what you’re doing in the kitchen.

Why does my French toast turn out soggy?
Usually you soaked it too long or your heat was too high. Quick dip, then onto the pan at that sweet spot—medium-low.

What if I only have regular sandwich bread?
Go for it, but it’ll be softer and might fall apart if you leave it in the egg mix too long. Sourdough’s sturdiness is why I love it.

Can I add mix-ins to the batter?
Heck yes. Spices, zests, or even a splash of bourbon for adults-only brunch.

Make Your Next Lazy Morning Legendary

So, Ultimate Homemade Sourdough French Toast isn’t fussy or flashy, but it does make a plain morning feel like a little event. You don’t even need special timing or fancy technique. Just a solid piece of sourdough, a few kitchen basics, and some love (cheesy but kinda true). If this recipe blew your mind, check out Delicious Sourdough French Toast for more ways to get creative. By the way, if you want to branch into other breakfast treats, try a look at this insanely good spiced pear ginger crumble or boost your mornings with delicious easy homemade granola bars. Go on, your happy breakfast future is waiting.

Print