Frozen Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Cocktail

INTRODUCTION

This Frozen Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Cocktail is a creamy, frozen drink that tastes like a dessert. It mixes peanut butter cups, vodka, and Baileys for a sweet, smooth drink. You can make it in a few minutes with a blender. It is a fun drink for a party or a quiet night at home.

If you like peanut butter snacks, you might also enjoy a no-bake peanut butter banana energy bites recipe that is simple and healthy. Try that snack as a light bite with this cocktail to balance a sweet treat with a healthier choice: no-bake peanut butter banana energy bites.

This piece will show clear steps to make the cocktail. It will also show ways to make a lighter option, a high protein version, and ideas for storing or preparing ahead. The words are simple. The steps are clear. Let’s get started.

WHY YOU WILL LOVE THIS RECIPE

You will love this recipe because it is quick and fun. It comes together in minutes with a blender and common ingredients. It is a great party drink and an easy treat after dinner.

This recipe can be changed into a healthy version or a lighter option. You can cut sugar and calories by using low-fat cream or a sugar-free liqueur. You can make a high protein meal alternative by adding protein powder or Greek yogurt. It can also be a good pick for meal prep when you make a base mix and freeze it to blend later. For those watching carbs, a low carb twist can keep the taste but cut the sugar.

This drink is not a meal on its own, but the high-protein version can be a rich, filling treat. The recipe is flexible, so people who want a lower calorie or low carb version will find easy swaps.

HOW TO MAKE Frozen Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Cocktail

This section shows the main steps. Read the tips and small swaps to make a lighter option. Use simple swaps like low-fat cream, sugar-free syrup, or a protein boost to make it fit your needs.

If you want a dessert that feels rich but acts lighter, try a peanut butter sundae inspired drink for flavor notes and tips on low-cal swaps: peanut butter sundae bliss.

Follow the simple steps below to make this frozen cocktail just the way you like it.

EQUIPMENT NEEDED

• Blender (strong enough to crush ice)
• Measuring jigger or small measuring cups
• Cocktail glass or chilled glass
• Spoon for layering chocolate syrup
• Knife and small plate for garnish prep
• Freezer-safe container (optional for make-ahead mixes)

Ingredients You’ll Need :

• 5-6 Medium Sized Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
• 2 oz Vodka
• 1.5 oz Baileys
• 1 oz Cream
• Ice
• Chocolate Syrup
• Cacoa Bits

STEP-BY-STEP INSTRUCTIONS :

In a blender add 4-5 of your Reese’s PB Cups, your vodka, baileys, and cream. Add ice and blend. Continue to add ice until it reaches your preferred consistency. In your cocktail glass add Chocolate Syrup along the inner glass. Pour in your frozen cocktail mixture. Garnish with Cacoa Bits and your leftover reese’s pb cup. Enjoy!

HOW TO SERVE Frozen Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Cocktail

Serve this cocktail in a chilled glass for best taste. Drizzle chocolate syrup inside the glass before pouring in the drink. Add one whole Reese’s PB cup on the rim or on a small plate next to the glass. Top with cacao bits for a crunchy touch.

For portion control, serve in small glasses. One 6-8 ounce glass is a good single serving. If you serve larger glasses, make a note of the calories and alcohol content. Serve slowly and enjoy each sip. If you want a lighter option, pour half of the usual drink and top with crushed ice or a splash of club soda to stretch the drink without more alcohol.

Keep healthy sides small and simple. A bowl of fresh berries or a light Greek yogurt dip can balance the sweet cocktail. For a mindful night out, drink water in between cocktails.

STORAGE & FREEZING : Frozen Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Cocktail

You can store the blended mix for short times. If you have leftover blended drink, pour it into an airtight container and put it in the freezer for up to 1 week. Let it thaw slightly, then re-blend for a smooth texture.

To store base mix before blending, combine the liquid parts and crushed peanut butter cups in a freezer-safe bag. Freeze this base for up to 1 month. When ready, put the base in the blender with fresh ice and blend to serve.

For safety, do not refreeze a drink that has been thawed more than once. The texture may change, and dairy can show changes in flavor. Label containers with the date to keep track.

SERVING SUGGESTIONS

Pair the cocktail with a small, balanced side. Good options are:

• Fresh strawberries or raspberries for a bright contrast
• A small bowl of mixed nuts for texture and healthy fats
• Low-sugar Greek yogurt with a sprinkle of cocoa for protein
• A small portion of dark chocolate (70% cocoa) for added depth

If you want a low calorie side, choose fresh fruit. For a higher protein option, serve a small scoop of Greek yogurt on the side. A balanced pairing will make the treat feel like part of a smarter plan.

You can also try a warm drink before or after to change the mood. For a calm evening, serve a light floral latte to follow this drink. If you like floral notes with sweet drinks, check out this lavender silk latte for a soothing finish: butterfly pea lavender silk latte.

VARIATIONS

This cocktail can change to fit many needs. Here are clear swaps.

• Healthier version

  • Use low-fat or unsweetened almond milk instead of cream.
  • Replace Baileys with a low-calorie or sugar-free Irish cream.
  • Use sugar-free chocolate syrup or a light cocoa dust.

• High-protein or low-carb version

  • Add one scoop of unflavored or chocolate protein powder to the blender. Mix well with the liquids before adding ice. This becomes a high protein meal-style shake.
  • Use a low-carb vodka or reduce the number of Reese’s cups to cut carbs. Use heavy cream sparingly or swap for a high-protein, low-sugar Greek yogurt to keep a creamy texture and boost protein. This low carb tweak can be good for people who want a treat but need to control carbs.

• Air fryer or oven-baked version if possible

  • You can bake or air fry a peanut butter cup crust to use as a garnish. Place mini peanut butter cups in the air fryer at low heat for 1-2 minutes to slightly melt and crisp the edges for a toasted garnish. This step adds a warm, nutty layer to the frozen cocktail.

These swaps let you make a lighter option, a high protein meal-replacement drink, or a fun warm garnish.

FAQ

Q: Can I make a lighter version that is low calorie?
A: Yes. Use unsweetened almond milk or low-fat cream and choose sugar-free syrup. Reduce the number of Reese’s cups to 2–3 and use less Baileys or a sugar-free cream liqueur. These swaps make a lower calorie drink that still tastes rich.

Q: Is there a diabetic-friendly way to make this cocktail?
A: You can make a diabetic-friendly version by using sugar-free chocolate syrup, a low-carb sweetener, unsweetened almond milk, and smaller servings of peanut butter cups. Also keep portions small and pace drinks with water.

Q: How long can I store the blended drink?
A: Store the blended drink in an airtight container in the freezer for up to 1 week. Thaw slightly and re-blend before serving. Do not refreeze after thawing more than once.

Q: Can this be a high protein meal replacement?
A: Yes. Add a scoop of protein powder or a half cup of Greek yogurt. This change turns the drink into a high protein meal or snack. Use low-sugar protein powder for fewer calories.

Q: Is this recipe gluten free?
A: Most Reese’s peanut butter cups are gluten free, but always check labels. Use gluten free chocolate syrup and other labeled gluten free ingredients if you need to avoid gluten.

Q: What is the best way to freeze a make-ahead mix?
A: Combine the liquids and crushed peanut butter cups in a freezer safe bag and freeze flat. Thaw slightly and blend with fresh ice when ready to serve.

MAKE-AHEAD TIPS FOR Frozen Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Cocktail

Make the base ahead to save time. Chop or crush the peanut butter cups and mix them with the vodka and Baileys. Freeze the base in small portions. When you want a drink, add the base to a blender with ice and cream. This is great for meal prep and for parties.

For parties, make the base the day before. Freeze it in portions for easy access. Keep chocolate syrup and cacao bits separate until serving. Garnish at the last minute for the best look and taste.

If you make a high-protein version, mix the protein powder with a small amount of liquid to avoid clumps before freezing the rest. Label each pack with contents and date. This saves time and helps portion control.

Print